Moses Did Not Write the Torah

 According to Jewish tradition, the entire Torah (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy) , both written and oral, was dictated to Moses at Mount Sinai about 1500 BCE.

The Truth Is…

Today no serious biblical scholar (i.e. one who does biblical research without looking for “evidence”to support biblical doctrine)  maintains that the Torah was dictated by God to Moses around 1500 BCE. None of those books were written by someone named Moses. Today, the majority of scholars agree that the Torah does not have a single author, and that its composition took place over centuries. In addition, modern scholars point out that there is no evidence that Hebrews were even able to write, nor any evidence of written Hebrew literature of any kind prior to the 10th Century BCE. True revelation can never be in disagreement with human reason and experience

The Documentary Hypothesis

The “Documentary Hypothesis” suggests that the five books were created c.450 BCE by combining four originally independent sources, known as

  • the Jahwist, or J (about 900 BCE),
  • the Elohist, or E (about 800 BCE),
  • the Deuteronomist, or D, (about 600 BCE),
  • and the Priestly source, or P (about 500 BCE).

In short, there are many people engaged in biblical scholarship who can demonstrate that the Torah is not the product of a single person, especially someone named Moses. The Documentary Hypothesis is quite scholarly and detailed and convincing to those who read it with an unbiased mind. It is not the point of this section to go into the detail required for an understanding of the Documentary. For a detailed explanation of the Documentary Hypothesis, click HERE.

Food for thought:

  • Isn’t it strange that the name of the Pharaoh causing the Jews all of their problems is never named? Even today, we know the names of the Pharaohs back to the first dynasty. We suspect the offending pharaoh is never named because who ever wrote Exodus, long after the alleged events, had no clue as to the names of any of the Pharaohs. The bible can relate a genealogy 40 levels deep but can’t name the Pharaoh of Moses time?
  • Isn’t it strange that a book written by Moses describes his own death and events that occurred after his death. .
  • Isn’t it strange that in a book written by Moses, he still uses his name instead of the pronoun “I”. That is the text will say “And the LORD said unto Moses…”. Why doesn’t it say “And the LORD said unto ME…”? Or it will say “Moses and Aaron … “; why doesn’t Moses say “Arron and I …”?
  • The phrase “…to this day” appears in many passages. “To this day” is not the phrase of someone describing a contemporary situation. It is rather the phrase of a later writer who is describing something that has happened in the past and endured “to this day”.

5 comments on “Moses Did Not Write the Torah

  1. Roger Glasgow says:

    Jesus said Moses gave you the law I bring you the truth and grace could he be referring to laws given to enforce the Ten Commandments add by others starting with Moses ? By verbal doctrine like the Mishnah ? Also did Moses really by yahwee ie Jesus really have children murdered pre crossing into the promised land or were the people really influenced by Satan ? There are sone contradictions in places

  2. Justin says:

    Isn’t it strange none of this biblical supernatural stuff has occurred in 2000 years. It never did.

  3. Lila Sharma says:

    You are right about this. And Paul was a Pharisee, so he believed everything that was written in the Old Testament. It was the priests that wrote the account about homosexuality. In the new testament, we really only have Paul who talks about homosexuality (depending on the translation). Therefore, the prohibitions against homosexuality do not come from God.

  4. Bryan Wilzig says:

    There was no papyrus to write on since
    it wasn’t taken out of Egypt on the Exodus.

New Evidence? Comments?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s